Recently, the public was shocked by the removal of a song by a local punk band, Sukatani. The song titled “Bayar, Bayar, Bayar” was pulled from all music platforms on Friday, Feb. 14, 2025.
Sukatani members announced the withdrawal via social media, along with an apology to the Police Institution.
This sparked negative public opinion against the police, who were perceived as being anti-criticism and suppressing artistic expression.
Professor Wahyudi Kumorotomo, a Public Policy Management expert from Universitas Gadjah Mada, commented on the controversy.
According to him, this case demonstrates that public institutions, such as the police, are not prepared to accept criticism from the public.
“Even though the band members have apologized, the public understands that it was likely due to police intimidation,” he said on Monday (Mar. 3).
Professor Kumorotomo explained that freedom of expression is guaranteed by the constitution, namely Law No. 39/1999 and Law No. 9/1998.
However, it seems that the police have yet to grasp its essence. He believes that Sukatani’s song ‘Bayar Bayar Bayar’ was created as a form of criticism of the police’s performance so far.
Almost all of the lyrics represent the public’s frustration with rogue police officers involved in extortion.
“The police should take responsibility for protecting and maintaining civil security,” he said.
Professor Kumorotomo further emphasized that institutions should not oppose freedom of speech. Criticism should be viewed as input to improve the institution’s performance for the public.
“It is very unfortunate that the Sukatani case actually portrays the institution as being unable to respond to constructive public criticism,” he remarked.
As known, the Sukatani case has further eroded public trust in the police.
A survey conducted by Litbang Kompas revealed that public trust in July 2024 was at 73.1%. However, by February 2024, it had declined to 71%.
Although the difference is slight, there is still a critical reaction from the public. This must be strengthened as a form of checks and balances for institutions and government policies.
Cases like the Sukatani band controversy may recur in the future.
Author: Tasya
Editor: Gusti Grehenson
Post-editor: Afifudin Baliya
Photograph: Instagram @sukatani.band