• News Archive
  • Simaster
  • Webmail
  • Directory
  •  English
    • Indonesia
Universitas Gadjah Mada Universitas Gadjah Mada Universitas Gadjah Mada Universitas Gadjah Mada
  • Education
    • Doctoral dissertation
    • Inauguration of Professor
    • Graduation
  • Achievement
  • Research and Innovation
    • Research
    • Innovation
  • Campus Info
    • Cooperation
    • Seminar and Workshop
    • Student Community Service Program
    • Other
  • News Report
  • Home
  • News Report
  • UGM Communication Expert: Avoids Multi-interpretation of Articles in ITE Law Revision

UGM Communication Expert: Avoids Multi-interpretation of Articles in ITE Law Revision

  • 17 February 2021, 14:03 WIB
  • By: Natasa Adelayanti
  • 670
  • PDF Version
Pakar Komunikasi UGM: Revisi UU ITE Hindarkan pasal Multitafsir

President Joko Widodo's statement that expected the public would openly criticize the Government on National Press Day summons various community opinions. This statement later then causes several opinions to emerge.

Although it was indicated by good intention, the community still was not convenient to implement because they still count to Law No. 11 of 2008 concerning Electronic Information and Transactions. There are articles in the law that are considered catchall articles and matters to criminalization.

Nyarwi Ahmad, Ph.D., a communication expert from Universitas Gadjah Mada, appraised that the community has implemented this kind of criticism through social media or electronic/online media. Regrettably, the ITE Law's presence is risky because several articles, such as article 27 paragraph 3 of article 28 paragraphs 1 and 2, are considered catchall articles.

Nyarwi suggested that there should be clarity about the hatred boundaries that covered what kind of outrage and lies. Because of these catchall articles, people are hesitant to criticize them.

"The thing is, to what extent does this article define criticism, what is the difference between criticism and hate speech, what is the difference between criticism and scattering lies. I believe the operational definition is very important to make people easier to understand what criticism actually is," he said at the UGM Faculty of Social and Political Communication Department on Wednesday (17/2).

If President Joko Widodo's statement during the National Press Day drives efforts to revise the ITE Law, Nyarwi counted it as a good step. Some of the reasons are that it can avoid multiple interpretations of its article meaning and avoid people's worries about evaluating the president's performance as the head of the state and all institutional leaders.

Nyarwi also said that regarding whether the revision was the best option or not, it is still possible because laws are made based on the momentum era and the needs.

"Government had already revised the ITE Law once in 2015. Kominfo submitted a revision, and the revision itself was considered quite progressive back then. We cannot directly complain as an offense to punish people from 6 years to 4 years. There must be a party who reports it or at least the related party," he said.

According to Nyarwi, criticism in a democracy is important because criticism can refresh, improve and renew government policies to be perfect and optimal in their works in order to be effective. Hence, the community needs to engage in the form of criticism.

Nevertheless, another thing that is necessary to be considered is the climate or democratic ecosystem that can appropriately elevate criticism and be conveyed properly. This condition is due to critics without arguments and without data not considered as criticism but mockery.

"Once again, this means that there should be an evaluation on the definition of the differences between criticism and non-criticism so there will not be multiple interpretations appeared and there must be an accommodation within regulations," he explained.

For Nyarwi, if a good and healthy ecosystem appeared within a democracy, there would also be healthy various public discussions and criticisms that can likely improve the government and state apparatus's performance. Accordingly, there must be an evaluation of the definition of criticism because criticism is considered freedom of expression guaranteed in Article 28 of the 1945 Constitution.

"So there will be protection and safety to those who convey their opinions or criticisms. It is fallacious if there is no clear regulation and it becomes a catchall article, and then it creates a gap of interpretation that makes people quiet. I think it is less profitable," he explained.

Nyarwi expected that a culture of good and healthy critical ethics would emerge. The elites are also expected to have a tradition of accepting or listening to criticism because criticism is a proper medium to evaluate their plans of ideas.

"That's how to strengthen our democratic system. Suppose this statement is an entry point for revision. In that case, it can also be a forum to clarify the definition of criticism and how it differs from hoax news, incitement, hate speech, and others. "Criticize is considered the community right to speak up and be protected by the 1945 Constitution. Hence, the House of Representatives of Republic Indonesia must accommodate the community's voice in the proper way of criticism, not the wrong one," he added.

Author: Agung Nugroho
Photo: merdeka.com
Translator: Natasa A

 

Related News

  • Broadcasting Law Revision Takes Side with Investors

    Thursday,29 December 2016 - 8:39
  • Revision to Regulation on Health Guarantee for the Disabled is Urged

    Friday,04 January 2013 - 10:56
  • UGM Legal Experts Urge Parliament Not to Amend Anti-corruption Commission Law

    Thursday,23 March 2017 - 9:01
  • Remote Sensing to Develop Student's Spatial Thinking

    Tuesday,07 November 2017 - 15:29
  • Earning Doctoral After Researching Gold Mining Area in Forest

    Wednesday,21 June 2017 - 13:25

News Releases

  • Agricultural Engineering Students Grab Medals at 2022 AE-ARC 20 May 2022
    UGM Agricultural Engineering students won four medals and
    Salma
  • UGM Students Win International Chess Tournament 19 May 2022
    UGM representatives have been named winners at the 25th GA
    Salma
  • UGM Researchers Breed New Black Soybean Cultivar 17 May 2022
    A team of researchers at the UGM Faculty of Agriculture is
    Salma
  • UGM Inaugurates New Professor of Chemical Engineering 13 May 2022
    Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM) celebrated the promotion of
    Salma
  • UGM Among World’s 10 Best Universities to Deliver SDG 1 10 May 2022
    Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM) was ranked in the top 10 glo
    Salma

Info

  • Install Fest Windows
    29 September 2017
  • Streaming Author Workshop Writing and Publishing
    14 July 2017
  • Hokkaido University Short Term Exchange Program HUSTEP
    08 January 2016
  • 2016 Amgen Scholars Program in Japan
    08 January 2016
  • Jardine Foundation Scholarship for Postgraduate Studies at University of Oxford and University of Cambridge
    01 July 2015

Event

  • 30May International Academic Conference on Tourism (INTACT) 2022 ...
  • 21Jul The International Conference on Sustainable Environment, Agriculture, and Tourism (ICOSEAT)...
  • 07Sep The 8th International Conference on Science and Technology (ICST 2022)...
Universitas Gadjah Mada
UNIVERSITAS GADJAH MADA
Bulaksumur Yogyakarta 55281
   info@ugm.ac.id
   +62 (274) 588688
   +62 (274) 565223
   +62 811 2869 988

PARTNERSHIP

  • Alumni
  • International Affairs

ABOUT UGM

  • Rector's Welcome
  • History
  • Vission and Mission
  • The Board of Executive
  • Management

VISIT UGM

  • Campus Map
  • Event

REGISTRATION

  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Vocational School
  • Professional Program
  • International Program

© 2022 Universitas Gadjah Mada

PRIVACY POLICYCONTACT